Mafia vs Werewolf: what is the difference?

It is the same game in two costumes. Mafia came first; Werewolf is the same hidden-role idea with a werewolf theme. What really differs is the rule set a table plays.

Play with AI players now

Who made Mafia, and when?

Wikipedia credits Dmitry Davidoff, then a psychology student, and dates the game to 1986 (Mafia (party game)). Andrew Plotkin, author of a well-known Werewolf rule set, writes on his own page that Davidoff invented it in 1986 (Plotkin’s page). The rules are public: The Original Mafia Rules.

Where does Werewolf come from?

According to Wikipedia, Andrew Plotkin added the werewolf theme in 1997, arguing that a hidden enemy who looks normal by day fits a werewolf better than a gangster. Wikipedia lists Werewolf as another name for the game.

What stays the same?

What differs between rule sets?

Details. Davidoff’s rules suggest about a third of the players as mafia and have no special roles; Plotkin’s Werewolf rules recommend two werewolves. Many sets add a night checker called detective, seer or sheriff. Which rule set the table plays matters more than the word mafia or werewolf.

What does MafiaVoice play?

Sport Mafia: ten seats, six civilians, a sheriff, two mafia and a don, seven red against three black. Everyone speaks for 60 seconds, may nominate one player a day, and the table votes in secret for 20 seconds. Ties, fouls, the last word and the best move have fixed numbers in the sport Mafia rules. The host is automatic: Mafia without a host.

Questions

Is Werewolf the same game as Mafia?

Wikipedia lists Werewolf as another name for Mafia, and Plotkin’s own page says Davidoff invented the game in 1986. The werewolf theme came later; the rules differ from one rule set to another.

Who invented Mafia?

Wikipedia credits Dmitry Davidoff, then a psychology student, and gives 1986. Andrew Plotkin’s Werewolf page says the same.

Which one is MafiaVoice?

MafiaVoice plays sport Mafia, with a sheriff and a don, at a table of ten.

Read next